Skip to main contentSkip to breadcrumbsHome

Methodology

How we verify, gate, and rank.

A plain-English explanation of where our data comes from, what every badge means, who can leave a review, and how search results are ordered. No black boxes.

Doctor verification

Every clinician on this site is matched to an active record in the federal NPPES NPI Registry, maintained by the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Listings without an NPI match are not published.

To claim a profile, a clinician signs in with an email tied to their NPI record or completes an out-of-band verification call. Claims are reviewed before the "Claimed & Verified" badge is granted.

Reviewer verification

We only count reviews from patients with a verified appointment or contact event recorded in our internal review-eligibility ledger. Every gated review displays a "Verified by appointment" label inline.

Imported third-party reviews (Google, Healthgrades, etc.) are shown for context with their source attribution but are excluded from the on-site rating and from ranking signals.

What each trust badge means

Every badge is a single, machine-checkable fact — no aggregate "quality scores."

  • Claimed & Verified

    Clinician (or authorized staff) has signed in and controls the profile. Edits are audited.

  • NPI Verified

    Identity matched against the NPPES National Provider Identifier registry. Required for every listing.

  • Board Certified

    Board certification language detected in the clinician's education and training record.

  • Accepting New Patients

    Self-reported by the practice on the claimed profile; revalidated quarterly.

  • Telehealth Available

    Offers virtual visits in addition to (or instead of) in-person care.

  • Years of Experience

    Computed from NPI enumeration date or self-reported graduation year.

Ranking factors

How search results are ordered

Results are deterministic. The same query returns the same order. Paid placement is always labeled and never replaces an exact specialty + city match.

WeightFactorWhat it measures
HighestSpecialty + location matchExact canonical-specialty match in the searched city, then within a 30-mile radius, then state-wide, then nationwide fallback.
HighProfile completenessPhoto, bio, services, procedures, education, insurance, phone, years of experience — each contributes to a 0–100 completeness score.
HighVerified review signalVolume, average rating, and recency of reviews from the gated review ledger. Imported third-party reviews shown separately and not counted in ranking.
MediumVisibility scoreHeadshot, 200+ char bio, 3+ Q&A, 3+ gallery items, NPI verified, 3+ verified reviews, ≥80% 24-hour lead response — see /dashboard.
MediumClaimed statusClaimed profiles outrank otherwise-equal unclaimed registry entries because data freshness is higher.
Labeled separatelyFeatured placementPaid Featured listings appear in a clearly labeled '★ Featured doctors' strip above the general list. They never displace an exact specialty + city match in the main results.

Worked examples

How the visibility score is calculated

Three real profile patterns. Each row shows what the doctor has done and the exact points it contributes to the 0–100 score — no hidden weighting.

Dr. A — newly claimed

NPI verified through registry match, just claimed the profile. No bio, no reviews, no Q&A yet.

15/100

Just claimed

  • Add a professional headshot0 / 15
  • Write a 200+ character bio0 / 15
  • Verify your NPI identity (Verified badge)+15
  • List 3+ services / procedures0 / 10
  • Answer 3 patient Q&A0 / 15
  • Add 3+ before/after photos0 / 15
  • Collect 3 verified patient reviews0 / 10
  • Respond to leads within 24 hours0 / 5

Dr. B — building credibility

Headshot uploaded, 240-char bio, services listed, board certified. Two verified reviews so far; responds to most leads within a day.

60/100

Strong

  • Add a professional headshot+15
  • Write a 200+ character bio+15
  • Verify your NPI identity (Verified badge)+15
  • List 3+ services / procedures+10
  • Answer 3 patient Q&A0 / 15
  • Add 3+ before/after photos0 / 15
  • Collect 3 verified patient reviews0 / 10
  • Respond to leads within 24 hours+5

Dr. C — featured-eligible

Complete profile: photo, 600-char bio, 5 services, 4 Q&A, 6 gallery items, 11 verified reviews, 92% 24-hour response rate.

100/100

Featured-eligible

  • Add a professional headshot+15
  • Write a 200+ character bio+15
  • Verify your NPI identity (Verified badge)+15
  • List 3+ services / procedures+10
  • Answer 3 patient Q&A+15
  • Add 3+ before/after photos+15
  • Collect 3 verified patient reviews+10
  • Respond to leads within 24 hours+5

Weights are fixed and identical for every clinician. Verified-review count and 24-hour lead-response rate keep the score sensitive to recent activity — a profile that goes silent loses eligibility for the Featured rotation until it re-engages.

Frequently asked

15 questions across 5 topics. Each answer also ships as structured data so search engines can surface the exact question and answer.

Verification

How are doctors verified on Help Me Find A Doctor?
Every listed clinician is matched to an active record in the federal NPPES National Provider Identifier (NPI) registry. To claim a profile, a doctor must sign in with an email tied to that NPI record or pass an out-of-band verification call. Claimed profiles get a 'Claimed & Verified' badge; unclaimed registry profiles are clearly marked.
What if the NPI registry has outdated information about a doctor?
Claimed profiles override stale NPPES fields for practice address, phone, accepted insurance, and specialty subfocus. Unclaimed profiles continue to display NPPES data as the source of truth, with a visible 'Unclaimed' label so visitors know it has not been confirmed by the clinician.
How do you confirm board certification?
Board certification is detected from parsed credentialing fields and the clinician's education and training record. We only display the 'Board Certified' badge when a board name and active status are present; expired or self-asserted certifications without a verifiable source are not badged.
Can a doctor be removed from the directory?
Yes. A verified clinician can request removal from their dashboard, and we honor takedown requests within 5 business days. We also remove profiles automatically when an NPI record is deactivated in NPPES.

Reviews

Who can leave a review?
Reviews are gated. Only patients with a verified appointment or contact event recorded in our doctor_review_eligibility ledger can submit a review, and each review carries a visible 'Verified by appointment' label. We do not accept anonymous, paid, or scraped reviews into the rated total.
How do you prevent fake or paid reviews?
Eligibility ledger entries are written server-side when a lead is submitted or an appointment is confirmed — they cannot be created from the client. Reviews without a matching ledger entry are blocked at submission, and any review that fails our spam, profanity, or sentiment-anomaly checks is held for manual review.
Can a doctor reply to or remove a negative review?
Doctors can publicly respond to any review from their dashboard. They cannot delete reviews. They can flag a review for policy violation (PHI, defamation, off-topic) and our team adjudicates within 5 business days, with the original reviewer notified of any action.
Do you show reviews from other sites?
We surface third-party review counts and average ratings for context, but they are displayed in a separate 'External reviews' section and do not contribute to our verified rating or ranking signal. Only gated, appointment-verified reviews are counted.

Badges

What do the trust badges mean?
Each badge maps to a single, machine-checkable fact: NPI Verified (registry match), Claimed & Verified (clinician control), Board Certified (parsed from credentialing), Accepting New Patients (self-reported, revalidated quarterly), Telehealth Available, and Years of Experience.
How often are 'Accepting New Patients' and similar status badges revalidated?
Status badges that depend on self-reported availability (Accepting New Patients, Telehealth Available, same-day visits) are revalidated quarterly. We prompt the clinician via email; if they do not confirm within 30 days the badge is automatically hidden until reconfirmed.

Ranking

How is search ranking determined?
Ranking is a transparent score: exact specialty + city match, distance within a 30-mile radius, profile completeness, verified review volume and recency, response rate to leads, and claimed status. Paid placement, when present, is labeled 'Featured' and never displaces an exact match.
Does paid placement affect ranking?
Featured listings appear in a clearly labeled '★ Featured doctors' strip above the general results, scoped to the same specialty and geography as the query. They are never inserted into, or allowed to displace, an exact specialty + city match in the unpaid list.
Why might a doctor's visibility score change week to week?
Two factors keep the score sensitive to recent activity: verified-review recency (older reviews carry less weight) and 24-hour lead response rate (computed on a rolling 30-day window). A previously high-scoring profile that goes silent loses points until it re-engages.

Data & privacy

Where does the underlying directory data come from?
Baseline identity and credentialing data come from the public NPPES NPI registry. Specialty-specific imports (UroLift, SignatureMD concierge, ABCS, DPC Alliance, AASCP, and others) are layered on top with strict NPI-match validation. Claimed profiles add clinician-supplied content (bios, photos, services, FAQs, gallery).
How can a patient correct or remove information about themselves?
We do not host patient records. Reviewer identity is pseudonymous in the public UI and stored encrypted. A reviewer can edit or delete their own review at any time from the original submission link; a request to fully erase associated data can be sent to our support address and is honored within 30 days.

Spot something wrong? Contact us or claim your profile to correct it directly.